Metal vs. Wooden Fence: Which is Best for Your Home?

Choosing a system encompassing your sanctuary can be daunting as the market has endless options. Which fences require the least maintenance, offer the best privacy, or enhance curb appeal? All these factors may affect your final decision. 

However, regardless of the overwhelmingness, the two most common types of fencing, metal and wooden fence, make it to the top of the list. Once you understand both fences’ pros and cons, you can pick the perfect fencing in no time. So, let’s dive into the explanation. 

Comparing Metal And Wooden Fence: Which One Is Better?

If you have decided to get a metal or wooden fence, although vinyl is still the preference of many, the final decision comes down to three things: the purpose of the fencing, the final look you want to attain, and the price you are willing to pay. [1]

1. Appearance

The first thing that fencing guarantees is its aesthetics. A wooden fence creates a warm and welcoming vibe; you can paint or stain them in different hues to complement your yard. Moreover, nowadays, many fence contractors also offer various styles that you can customize to your liking to enhance the curb appeal of your property. 

On the other hand, metal fencing creates a relatively modern and elegant look. However, depending on the design, it can sometimes also create an unwelcoming look (if you are not careful when selecting the design of the fence). On the bright side, these fences come in various colors with fence caps and decorative extensions for an artistic look. 

2. Durability

It is no secret that wooden fences are a budget-friendly option, one of the major reasons for their popularity. However, on the downside, wooden fencing is more vulnerable to rot and temperature extremes and may require frequent maintenance. Some estimations say that wood fencing lasts about 15 years with good maintenance [1]. Thus, it may cost more as the years pass. 

In contrast, metal fences require more budget but offer more resistance against the outdoor extremes. On average, they can last at least 30 to 40 years with little to no maintenance. It means that once you spend the budget on their initial installation, they’ll ensure you get your money’s worth. 

3. Installation 

Wooden fence reacts to changing temperatures. For instance, after the initial installation, the wood shrinks around ¼ inches [2] as it dries, often resulting in unnecessary gaps between the fencing. Moreover, the doors swell during cold months, making it difficult to open or close them properly. 

In comparison, there are no such complications with metal fencing. However, it can be heavy to install as it’s an intricate metal property. Therefore, manufacturers or fence contracting companies have different tools to ease their installations. Unlike wooden ones, metal fencing is also a good choice for uneven terrain. 

4. Types 

Wooden and metal fences are of different types depending on the material used. Each one has its pros and cons, so it is important to have some insights about them to select the right fencing. 

Types of Metal Fencing

Aluminum Fences: These are the most common metal fences in various heights, sizes, and designs. They are the most affordable and don’t require regular maintenance. They are commonly used for pool or garden enclosures but also make a good pick for yard boundaries.  

Chain Link Fences: Chain-link fences get their name from their chain-like structure, guaranteeing excellent visibility and airflow. They are ideal for enclosing playgrounds, industrial areas, or large properties. 

Wrought Iron Fences: The last one is the wrought iron fence, also called ornamental iron, and is preferred for its elegance and durability. However, to ensure a good appearance, it needs regular maintenance. 

Types of Wooden Fences

Pine Fences: Pine fences are another popular wooden fence because of their affordability and longevity. Furthermore, it makes a good pick for picket fences or privacy boundaries on a budget. 

Cedar Fences: These are naturally resistant to insects and premature wear. Their warm and rustic appearance makes them ideal for privacy and horizontal fences. It weathers to a silver-grey hue if left unstained, creating an antique look. [3]

Timber Fences: Timber fences are ideal for properties following classic architecture or country-side homes. Their most common inclination is seen in picket fences. Although they may peel away with time, they can last longer if painted with resistant coats. 

5. Security

Another reason why homeowners tend to install fencing is to ensure security. This factor can vary depending on your preference, whether you are looking to install a fence to confine your pets or need security against trespassing on the property. 

Wooden fences no doubt offer good security for pets. However, they are relatively easy to cut through or climb. So, if you are living in areas with higher crime rates, it may not be the optimal choice. In comparison, metal fencing offers much better security as it is difficult to climb or damage. Furthermore, they also come with anti-dig and non-climb designs to extend protection. 

6. Privacy 

The last factor that distinguishes the two fencing types is privacy. As logic agrees, wooden fences have fewer gaps and can be designed to decrease the fence distance further to provide more privacy. 

On the other hand, metal fencing offers significantly less privacy as there is more distance between the fences and other design elements that allow visibility. 

Wrap Up

Wood and iron fences are the two most popular fences among homeowners. However, still, there is no set-in-stone answer to this question, as it solely depends on your needs and preferences. 

Metal fences work best if you are looking for longevity, low maintenance, and high security. But if you want aesthetics, privacy, and a budget-friendly solution, wooden fences are your go-to. If you are still uncertain about which fence will be perfect for you, you can contact the customer care of Affordable Fence Pros for guidance. We can help you pick the ideal fence and offer customized quotes based on your requirements. 

FAQs

  1. Are wooden fences cheap or metal ones?

Wooden fences have lower upfront costs, but they may prove expensive over time since they require periodic maintenance. In comparison, metal fences are relatively costly, but they prove inexpensive over time since they need zero maintenance. 

  1. How long can a wooden fence last?

Wooden fences commonly last for 15 to 20 years with proper maintenance [1], but depending on the weather conditions, the fence may also wear before this period. 

  1. Which fencing is more eco-friendly, metal or wooden fence?

Wooden fencing is generally more eco-friendly than metal fencing due to its renewable nature and lower carbon footprint. However, steel fences are also environmentally friendly as they are recyclable. [4] 

  1. Are fences really important?

Yes, fences add to the appeal of your property, keep out predators, and provide safety to your pets. Furthermore, they also add a protective barrier to prevent property damage. 

External Links

[1]https://barrierboss.ca/blogs/news/wood-vs-metal-fencing-investment 

[2]https://fortressbp.com/blog/95/the-great-debate-wood-vs-metal-fencing

[3]https://buzzfence.com/metal-vs-wood-fencing-comparison/  

[4]https://www.birkdalesales.com/blogs/garden-fence-questions/eco-friendly-fence-options-for-your-home#:~:text=Metal%20fencing,repurposed%20at%20end%20of%20life

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *